signifies winner
"CH" signifies item found on club hunt
| Oldest Identifiable Coin | |
| Item | Found By |
|---|---|
| Darrell Mason (Fisher CoinStrike) | |
| No date large cent | Keith Armentrout |
| No date large cent | John Rebman |
| Cut piece of a 3-cent piece | Jim Tamosaitis |
| 1895 Indian head penny | Bill Draper |
| No date Indian head | Warren Timmons |
| 1940 wheat penny | Richard Davey |
| Club Favorite | |
| Item | Found By |
|---|---|
| Jim Tamosaitis (Minelab Explorer) | |
| 1849 Seated Liberty dime | Bill Draper |
| 1860's large cent CH | John Rebman |
| 1894 Indian head penny CH | Darrell Mason |
| 1902 Barber dime CH | Barbara Eppolite |
| 1907 Barber dime CH | Darlene Stevens |
| 1911 Barber dime CH | Warren Timmons |
| 1926 S wheat penny | Millard Johnson |
| Relic | |
| Item | Found By |
|---|---|
| Richard Davey (Bounty Hunter) | |
| Piece of green insulator | Ed Donovan |
| Old ceramic fuse holder/insulator | Barbara Eppolite |
| 1947 wheat penny CH | Warren Timmons |
| Sterling thimble w/ floral design CH | Keith Armentrout |
| Silver-plated decorative button | Bill Draper |
| Front of mid-1800's boot pistol CH | Darrell Mason |
| Confederate Civil War eagle button | Jim Tamosaitis |
| Watch key for pocket watch CH | John Rebman |
| Homemade button made from token or coin | Millard Johnson |
| Jewelry | |
| Item | Found By |
|---|---|
| Jim Carmine (Minelab Excalibur) | |
| .925 silver horseshoe ring | John Rebman |
| Adjustable plated ring w/ inlaid stone design | Barbara Eppolite |
| Sterling signet ring w/ onyx | Millard Johnson |
| Piece of earring | Jim Tamosaitis |
| Drawer pull/escutcheon | Richard Davey |
| Decorative button | Bill Draper |
| Costume jewelry ring w/ black stone CH | Warren Timmons |
| Costume jewelry ring | Ed Donovan |
| Miscellaneous | |
| Item | Found By |
|---|---|
| Jim Tamosaitis (Minelab Explorer) | |
| Lead shield w/ design CH | Darrell Mason |
| Gold-plated button | Richard Davey |
| Tomato peeler token | Keith Armentrout |
| "Private Detective" badge | Millard Johnson |
| "Society of Stoopnocracy" token | Barbara Eppolite |
| "Made in Taiwan" whistle | Warren Timmons |
| 1910 Excelsior Boy Scout Shoe Co. token | John Christian |
| Dinosaur family tree token | Bill Draper |
| Small keys | John Rebman |
| Lacy filigree heart pendant | Ed Donovan |